Jim feels guilty after his actions inadvertently injure a bystander. The Watcher proposes to Katie, Chris steals the trilsettum serum and injects it into his crippled father, and Mr. Litchfield forces JJ to join the academic decathlon team.

Jim refuses to let Stephanie help him stop a super-powered individual who is targeting her friend, she takes offense and the two end up in a competition to take out the bad guy. Meanwhile, Daphne objects when Jim lets JJ date a senior, but won’t let her do the same. And Katie learns something unexpected [...]

When Jim’s brother Mike learns that his brother has powers, he attempts to use JJ’s powers to win at the horse track. Meanwhile, Katie receives a promotion, and Daphne comes to believe a student accused of drug use is innocent.

Jim saves a man’s life, and bonds with him, his wife, and their kids. However, Jim wonders if their new friends are concealing something. Meanwhle, Daphen runs for student council President, and Katie talks to Stephanie about her boyfriend.

When George gets credit for one of Jim’s secret crimefighting activities, animosity breaks out between the two friends. Meanwhile, Daphne suspects something is wrong with Katie’s new boyfriend, JJ discovers a problem with his powers, and Stephanie and Katie disagree over a personal matter.